3-legged support: buying a tripod and head
This will be my next purchase. I want something light (3 lbs), good (sturdy and can support my 10D with its heaviest lens, the 200 F2.8), and cheap (<$200). It turns out that light and good never come cheap. Sigh.
| Light Tripod | Velbon Chaser EFL-4 | Bogen Manfrotto 3001 | Velbon Carmagne 630 or 640 | Gitzo Mountaineer 1228 |
| Type | Aluminum | Aluminum | Carbon Fiber | Carbon Fiber |
| Price (new) | $80 | $90 | $300 | $400 |
| Price (used) | - | $70 | - | $350 |
As for ballheads, the light (~1 lb) and good ones that make the list are all a couple hundred dollars.
| Light Ballhead | Kirk BH-3 | Acratech Ultimate Ballhead | Markins M10 |
| Price (new) | $240 | $280 | $320 |
| Price (used) | $190 | $240 | - |
And don't forget the plates. Only the Kirk BH-3 comes with a generic one. You might want to get a camera-specific one.
| QR plates | Kirk | Acratech | Really Right Stuff | Arca Swiss |
| Price (new) | $55 | $40 | $55 | $50 |
| Price (used) | $40 | $30 | $40 | $35 |
Right now, my options are
- spending a heck of a lot of money for "the one"--something great that I would probably never upgrade again ($600 for Hakuba/Velbon Carmagne 630 CF legs, and an Acratech Ultimate ballhead). If I were rich, I would go for the fancy Gitzo Mountaineer CF legs.
- going cheaper on the legs and getting the lightest coolest ballhead ($400 for Velbon EFL-4 AL legs, and the Acratech Ultimate ballhead)
- going really cheap, but facing the possibility of upgrading in a couple months down the road ($100 for the Velbon EFL-4 and some cheap head)
Some useful links
- I highly recommend this article on tripods http://www.bythom.com/support.htm. It has convincing arguments on why one shouldn't cheap out on tripods.
- A comparison of light and affordable tripod legs http://members.bellatlantic.net/~vze2gkrc/Tripod-Test.html
- Modified Velbon Carmagne 630 by Arca
- Velbon Carmagne 630 review
- Review of Velbon EFL-4 cheap light-weight tripod
- Acratech Ultimate Ballhead
- Really Right Stuff Quick Release Plates
- Kirk Enterprises Ballheads
- Markins Ballheads
- Nikonian.org's Pro Photo Shop sells Markins

1 Comments:
Feisol Tripods seem to have quite a following at FredMiranda too. Its a little more expensive but it might be worth it since its carbon fibre.
So a Feisol plus Acratech will increase the price to $520 from Velbon + Acratech = $400.
Post a Comment
<< Home